Use this free fountain pen paper comparison sheet to record how two papers behave with your own nib and ink. It separates feathering, show-through, bleed-through and smearing, so you can choose a notebook for the way you write.
Download the free comparison sheet
A one-page PDF for printing and handwriting. No email address or account is required.
Download the paper comparison sheet (PDF)
A4 portrait. For US Letter, choose “Fit” or “Fit to printable area” in your print dialog. Write your test samples on the papers you are comparing, and record the results on this sheet.
This is an original WabiFinds recording tool, not a laboratory protocol or a set of product test results. It contains no product rankings or affiliate links. Our related buying guides contain disclosed affiliate links.
How to compare two fountain pen papers
- Identify both samples. Record the notebook name, exact edition, ruling and stated paper weight. Note the date and which side of the paper you use. A paper name alone may cover different editions.
- Keep the writing setup the same. Use the same pen, nib, ink and short sentence for Paper A and Paper B. Write with your usual pressure and hand position. If you change the ink or nib, start a new sheet.
- Look at the line edges. Record whether fine strokes stay distinct or spread into fuzzy edges. Use the same lighting and viewing distance for both samples.
- Check the reverse separately. Note writing visible through the sheet as show-through. Record ink reaching the reverse as bleed-through. Do not count all visible writing on the back as ink penetration.
- Try separate timed smear checks. Write a fresh short line for each 5, 15, 30 and 60-second check. Touch each line once at its assigned time, using the same method on both papers. Do not repeatedly rub a single line and call it a drying-time test.
- Decide by your own priorities. A notebook for quick page turns may call for different trade-offs from one used to enjoy ink appearance. Record the size, binding and local delivered price alongside your observations.
What the observations mean
| Observation | What to record |
|---|---|
| Feathering | Fuzzy or spreading edges on the writing side. |
| Show-through / ghosting | Writing visible through the sheet. Decide whether it distracts you when using both sides. |
| Bleed-through | Ink reaching the reverse side, assessed separately from show-through. |
| Smearing | Whether the fresh line moves or transfers at the time you check it. This does not establish an exact drying time. |
For background on the interaction between pen, ink and paper, see Goulet Pens’ explanation of why paper matters. The worksheet layout and comparison routine are WabiFinds’ own editorial work; the linked article is not an endorsement of this sheet.
Before drawing a conclusion
Repeat with a second sample if the difference is small. Results can vary with ink, nib, paper batch, humidity and technique. A sample that works well for one pen does not prove that a whole notebook range works equally well with every ink.
If you write left-handed, include your normal hand position and page-turning pace. Ask permission before writing on a shop sample. You can begin with papers you already own; buying a set of notebooks is not required.
Find a notebook or pen to compare
- Japanese notebooks for fountain pens: paper, ruling and format
- Beginner Japanese fountain pens: nib and refill checks
- Hobonichi versus TRAVELER’S Notebook: dated pages or flexible refills
Printing and paper-testing FAQ
Do I write on this printed sheet to test the paper?
Write the samples on the two notebook papers you are comparing. Use this PDF to record those observations. Printing the worksheet on ordinary printer paper does not test the notebook paper.
Can I print it on US Letter?
The file is A4 portrait. Select “Fit” or “Fit to printable area” for US Letter and check the preview before printing. This is a recording sheet, so reducing its scale does not change the paper comparison.
Does a five-second smear mean the paper is unsuitable?
It records what happened with that nib, ink and check method at that moment. Use a fresh line for each timed check and decide whether the result suits your own page-turning pace. The blank sheet contains no WabiFinds test results.
You may print and share the blank PDF unchanged with WabiFinds attribution, including in a pen club or stationery workshop. Please link to this page so readers can find the instructions and current version. Do not present blank fields as completed WabiFinds test results.
Prepared by WabiFinds. Version 1.0, October 31, 2026. No photographs or generated images are used in this worksheet.
